Results
winner of anniversary Robotour is Kamaro Engineering!
The 10th year of Robotour contest, which took place in Písek, had several specials. There were several runs directly in the city, i.e. not only park roads. And the biggest surprise was victory of new German team from Karlsruhe!
Competition
Attendance
There were nine teams registered and also nine teams actively participated .
In reality instead of AmBot, which had serious troubles the day before contest
and its participation canceled, started another German team
JECC2. There was only one Robotour
novice this year: team Kamaro Engineering, which we met on contest
Field Robot Event 2015. To be honest I was
not quite sure if they will come. But they did, their robot moved and with a
bit of luck they won the contest!
The Place
It would not be the group from Písek, if they would not prepare something
special. There were
prepared quite challenging sections, in excuse that 10th year desires something extra. The runs were partially in parks, i.e. on park
roads, but also on normal street, cobbles and surfaces with various colors.
There was even cemetery, or better „reverential place”, where I was a
bit uncomfortable, but there were also weddings and youngsters played there
football, so the robots behaved with more respect to the deceased.
Another tricky place was a pedestrian bridge with wheelchair accessible slope to an
island. And if you think that this is was it, what about passageway
through house, which leads from the square to park „Palackého sady”? This is the
big park you may know from Robotem rovně
contest. What pleased me was the fact that no team complained. Just the
opposite, several teams priced highly this city tour.
0th and 1st Run
Zero run, where we review start procedure, was surprisingly not that chaotic as
previous years. The start and goal was then the same also for the first run.
We were witnesses of Murphy's law in practise — Kamaro Engineering
completed the straight park road, crossed the street and find the way through
the gate to cemetery. Then they choose wrong direction to avoid the tree and
left the road. That was the practise run. In the real run the robot did not
even start.
JECC2 went on odometry only, without GPS. The robot was only several
hours old so it was nice to see that it worked reasonably well, and the full
barrel was not a problem.
The winner from last year Smelý Zajko entered
with new dose of courage loaded into its neural network. There was a new sensor (laser scanner Hokuyo), which
kept robot away from the cemetery wall. After several minutes of hesitation
with motion a little there and a little back the direction from camera finally
won and in the real run Smelý Zajko managed to enter the gate, went through
the place of rest and leave through small gate on the other side. Its run was
terminated by an another trap: white car on the parking place. The color was
classified as potential road but dark wheel were not. And so the robot oscillated
and never left the white car. The next year this situation should be solved
by better integration of new LIDAR.
I would mention one more luckless fellow: MarS. Also here played the camera
primary part for navigation and the concrete columns colored like the road
attracted the robot and caused collision.
And what about E_liška from Radioklub Písek? She went fine, but missed the
gate. She flirt a while with the cemetery wall but then we were witnesses of AI
in practice (carper would probably say luck only), when she replanned the road and
choose an alternative around the cemetery. And she almost succeeded (the
failure was near the goal).
2nd Run
The second run was recorded from the air by Dan Polák, so you can have a look:
This shots look like some mass accident on robotic highway to me. It was
supposed to be a simple run, but it was not. The start was on a cycle path
along river Otava, slightly curved. The direction south — so was the sun the
source of
problems? There were strips painted on the road, was that the problem? I do not
know. In any case robots had problems and nobody completed the first curve. This means that
also nobody reached the first crossing to turn left on the bridge and second junction to the
island. Once a while it was adrenalin, for example when E_liška wrongly
evaluated surface change and turn left. There was steep slope down to the river.
3rd Run
We decided not to trouble robots with the
uphill drive to „Putimská brána” after experience from the first two runs.
Instead we moved the start to the beginning
of pedestrian zone along the river. Teams and the batteries had some time to
recover over lunch break, and you could recognize that. Somebody would say,
that this was a simple track, somebody else just the opposite.
Well there were not many ways where you could turn away: there was a wall on the left
and houses on the right. But low kerb was killer for several robots. Also wide
dark sewer scare off for example MarS and it turned 180 degrees from it.
This run was a tragedy for so far winning E_lišku from team Radioklub
Písek. Due to repeated motion back and forth she broke the wheel and did not
participate in the remaining runs.
This run scored NDTeam and the most points gained Kamaro Engineering. They had
problem with their onboard computer so they mounted notebook on robot instead.
And it worked. After first runs experiences they removed from the code procedure
to return to
the start … and I believe that they would not reach the goal if the code was still
there. So it was the only team which managed to navigate between houses and
narrow streets along the river all the way to Stone bridge. They finished 8
meters from the goal because their goal radius was set to 10m.
4th Run
The last run was on a wide street, cobblestones, uphill. These conditions did
not suite in particular to MarS — small robot did not have enough power to pull
the carriage with beer and small wheels turned in joint between tiles. Kamaro
scored again and a lot. I expected that there are only two ways how to enter
the park though houses, but they found the third one. Unfortunately it was very
narrow with restaurant table on both sides so there was no chance to guess
the correct direction. Even though the goal was just on the other side of the house and it
was enough to convincing victory!
Total Score
Place | Team | 1st Run | 2nd Run | 3rd Run | 4th Run | Total |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. | Kamaro Engineering | 0 | 12 | 385 | 221 | 618 |
2. | Radioklub Písek | 148 | 74 | 0 | - | 222 |
3. | Smelý Zajko | 122 | 0 | 3 | 31 | 156 |
4. | ARBot | 0 | 28 | 12 | 86 | 126 |
5. | NDTeam | 0 | 2 | 75 | 0 | 77 |
6. | MarS | 44 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 46 |
7. | JECC2 | 26 | 0 | 0 | 9 | 35 |
8. | Istrobotics | 4 | - | 17 | 2 | 23 |
9. | JECC | 0 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
Workshop and PAIR'15
There was a „classic” workshop on Sunday. It was coordinated with student
conference PAIR'15 (Planning in
Artificial Intelligence and Robotics) this year, organized by ČVUT FEL Praha.
The overlap was useful for both sides: students learned something from
experiences of Robotour participants and competitors got some idea about current
status of scientific research. The invited talk was about Roboauto presented by
Honza Najvárek.
Technology
There were some interesting technologies used by teams this year:
- Odroid (NDTeam, Istrobotics)
- laser scanner vacuum cleaner (Istrobotics, Kamaro Engineering)
- FPGA (ARBot)
- modified BLDC motors in wheel (Radioklub písek)
Roboauto
Nice „diversification” of the competition was visit of Roboauto from Brno. You
may remember them from previous years, when their robots finished on leading
places. Now they experiment with modified car Hundai i40 and they presented
small demo to groups of robotics in Písek. Do not worry if you missed that —
there is going to be a chance to see the car on Robotem rovně 2016, where
the goal is to participate and autonomously navigate through the park .
Plans for Robotour 2016
If everything goes fine then the next Robotour is going to be in Germany
(Deggendorf). Note, that we also plan some small changes in the rules. In particular there will be
possibility to load/unload barrel (50 points if robot pass the start line).
Also 500ml cans will be allowed instead of the big barrel, but the robot has to be
able to load them (5 points per can, max 10 pieces). We will keep the
reverse order on start, i.e. the currently best team will start from the last
position.
Thanks
I would like to thank a lot to Radioklub Písek for preparation and perfect
realization of jubilee Robotour.
If you would like to somehow support this contest or you have some
comment/query, please use our contact form.